From Problems to Profit
Winning Customers in the Worst Times
Contents
1 The Problem
It's four-thirty in the afternoon. It has been a difficult day, but it's nearly over. The phone rings with a call from your new customer. They have placed a couple of big orders with you, and if things go well you could be putting everything onto their site. 'Hello Alan, everything alright?' you ask. 'Tom, these windows we've been waiting three weeks for have just arrived' comes the reply. 'Oh good' you say, a feeling of slight apprehension starting to rise 'they ok?'. 'We ordered them stained. These are white primed... The bomb has dropped.
The first thing that goes through your mind is 'is it my fault?, did I order them wrong?'.The second thing is 'did he order it wrong, how am I going to sort this out?'.
Or how about this one? A customer came in three days ago in a desparate panic for bricks - on a job they've taken on at the last minute. Without the time to go through the normal brick match procedure you recommended one from the catalogue. The customer ordered them and they've just arrived on site. Now he's on the blower - "Tom, I don't like them. They're nothing like the catalogue, they'll have to go back".
So what now? You've got a serious problem. It may or may not be your fault - but one thing is certain, you have to deal with it.
2 It Happens
Problems will always happen. No matter what you do in life, or where you go, you'll always find problems and difficulties. The thing is, any customer who's been around the block more than once knows this too.
2.1 Why Does It Matter?
If you're reading this, the chances are that you work in the building materials supply industry - and probably in a builders merchant. Let's take this opportunity to understand the nature of our business.
You're a middle man. You earn your living by selling things that other people manufacture. So why should people buy things from you? Here are a few of the reasons :
- Geographical convenience
- Because of your bulk purchasing power, you can actually offer them a better price than the manufacturer will
- They aren't aware they can go direct to the supplier
- They don't have the expertise required and need help sourcing and specifying materials
- They don't want the hassle of having to deal with lots of suppliers - but want the convenience of someone who looks after them
Number one may hold true for yard sales - but it needn't be true for direct to site business. Just because you're the only merchant in town doesn't mean the customer will give you all his big orders. Remember - this reason is going to work against you as often as it will for you. Your customers do out of town jobs too.
Numbers two and three are certainly reasons for a customer to use a merchant - but no reason for them to use you. The same holds for the competition.
In numbers four amd five we see where you can distinguish yoursef. In expertise and service are the reasons that a builder will want to buy his materials through you, rather than anyone else.
The merchant trade may seem similar to the retail trade - but it is actually more like a service industry. You earn your bread and butter not because you can supply goods - but because you provide a service that the customer needs.
2.2 The Opportunity
It's easy enough to do business when things are going well. You have a laugh with the customer (well... some of them), you make money and everyone's happy - anyone can do that. What really counts is how you handle it when things go wrong. Your customer needs to know that if the worst happens, you'll be fighting on their side. Everyone has had the experience of being dropped in it by a supplier who just doesn't care.
This means that problems can be an opportunity to win your customer - even if they don't get exactly what they want. If they know that you're willing to put yourself out to support them when the brown stuff starts flying - then they'll trust you with their business.
3 Handling Crisis
So the question becomes not how can I make sure that problems never happen?, but instead how do I handle problems in the best way possible?.
Now let's get this straight though - minimising problems is good. Making careless mistakes is a sure way to lose business fast. But having said that, we still need to know the best way of dealing with problems.
One thing is certain - getting stressed isn't going to achieve anything. Blaming the customer is also guaranteed to make things worse. These may both be entirely natural reactions - but there is no way they're actually going to help.
The golden rule is stay calm and stay polite.
If you can't immediately see a solution to the problem, then you need to create a bit of space to deal with it. Don't promise the customer anything, except that you are going to do your very best to sort this out as quickly as possible - even if you don't yet know how.
Quickly assess the situation as you understand it. Sometimes it's impossible to know the full reality without going on site - but you can take stock of what you do know (What was actually ordered, what the customer specified, etc).
The really important question to ask yourself is what do I need to do next in order to deal with this?.
This puts aside any question of blame and just deals with the practical issues - what can I actually do? If there's something you can't do, then there's little point in worrying about it. So long as you convey to the customer that you're doing as much as possible then they will appreciate it in the long run.
3.1 Taking the Flack
When things go wrong the natural human reaction is to want to blame and get angry. Not only do you have to recognize and temper that reaction in yourself - but you have to accept that this is how your customer feels too.
So when he (or she.. or they... or it...) phones up (or even worse comes in) and lets of steam - try and stay calm and professional. Very often, if you let them blow off steam they'll feel better - and be ready to face whatever needs to be done to sort the mess out.
3.2 The Science of Applied Pressure
The customer expects you to take responsibility for resolving the problem. You are his supplier and this is part of what he pays you for.
In the same way, you are the customer of your supplier. You have the right (indeed the duty) to expect and demand the same level of service from your supplier that you are giving to your customer.
This is part of the purpose of the assessment earlier. As clearly as possible work out what responsibilities lie with which party. The answer to this question is vital - because it determines how you act.
If it is straightforwardly a mistake on the part of the supplier (you ordered correctly but they delivered the wrong item) then you can apply the appropriate pressure to their sales office and representative. You need to guage how much force you can apply (the politeness-anger balance) before you actually demotivate people from helping you.
If the customer made the mistake then you need to politely but formly explain the position. "In actual fact Alan, you did order white primed. I've left a message with the rep though - and we'll see if there's anything they can do about it."
If it's your fault then sometimes you just have to put your hands up and admit the mistake. The customer may not be pleased, and it's likely to cost some money - but in the long run they appreciate honesty.
Sometimes it's not so clear though - the customer with the bricks for example. Whenever someone orders from a catalogue without seeing a sample there is a risk they will come a different shade. If you forgot, in the rush, to explain this to the customer - is the liability his or yours?
In this sort of situation there are various things you can try and do. Speak to the rep, even though they're not obliged to they might take them back. Explain the rules to the customer - he might accept a portion of the blame. What about a discount - will he accept thea bit cheaper? Some days you'll win, and some days you'll lose.
4 Minimise Risk
There are certain lessons that can be learned from problems. There are ways you can not only reduce the likelihood of problems - but also minimise the difficulty of resolving them too.
Here are a few guidelines.
4.1 Create Realistic Expectations
Make sure you create realistic expectations. Let your customers know how long goods will take to arrive, and explain any potential problems you're aware of. This way when they happen - your customer has had a chance to prepare themself (and is less likely to blame you).
A classic one is our example of the bricks - if the colour can vary from the catalogue, then you need to let your customer know.
Also don't oversell. If you promise things that don't arrive, or create an expectation you can't deliver, then your customer is right to feel let down.
4.2 Clearly Define Liabilities
Define where liabilities lie as clearly as possible. If they can't change the order after it's been placed, tell them that.
Many customers also assume they can return things they don't like. If this isn't the case then warn them about potential restocking charges.
Where things are out of your control and in the hands of the supplier it's worth letting the customer know this. Then the customer knows what is their responsibility (to properly specify and confirm details), what's yours (to order and liaise with the supplier), and what is the manufacturers responsibility (to produce the goods on time and to the specification).
If the responsibilities are clearly apportioned, when things start to go wrong the customer will know which things it's realistic to expect you to resolve - and which things have to be sorted by the maker.
4.3 The Paper Trail
The more details of the transaction you can keep available the better. (Note that hidden in a box somewhere is not the same as accessible). Better yet is to give the customer a copy of the final order. That way they are deemed to accept the details of the order as they are on your version. This can be a great help when trying to resolve discrepancies - as well as giving you more opportunities to pick up on mistakes.
Keeping track of conversations with suppliers gives you greater leverage when dealing with them. Taking the name of people you speak to is vital - a promise without a name is virtually valueless, because there is no-one to hold accountable.
4.4 Communicate Well During Problems
As a customer - there's little more frustrating than not knowing what is happening, or even if anyone takes your problems seriously.
The more you communicate with your customers the more they'll feel looked after. If the delay is with your supplier this is your opportunity to make that clear.
5 Conclusion
We can't eradicate problems altogether - but we've seen that how you cope with problems can be crucial in winning customer loyalty.
Our disaster recovery plan goes something like this :
Stay calm and stay polite - resist the pressure to get stressed or the temptation to apportion blame.
Assure the customer you are doing everything you can to sort out the situation (without making any promises as to what that may mean).
Assess the situation - try and work out what the situation is and where the responsibilities lie.
Work out (if necessary step by step) what you need to do next to resolve the situation.
You'll often be in one of these three positions :
- The supplier has messed up. You need to apply pressure on them to resolve it, whilst letting your customer know what is happening.
- It's your fault. Speak to the supplier to see if they can help, work out if there is anything else you can do to mitigate the loss - but you'll probably have to admit it to the customer.
- It's actually the customer's fault. Explain the situation calmly and firmly - whilst seeing if there is anything you can do to help.
The aim is to leave your customer feeling secure that when the brown stuff starts flying, you will do your best to sort it out. This way they'll trust you with their business, even when things don't go according to plan.
Also see: Blinds, Partner Directory.